I have been doing this for 5 years now. I usually order from 3 places.
Fishing Skirts gets most of my business. Never had an issue at all. Erin calls me if there is a problem with my order or something is out of stock and she has gotten permission by my wife to substitute something that would not be noticed in the full skirt and what not. Not once have I had a problem from them.
LurePartsOnline - Been ordering from them since I bought my first melting pot in November of 2010 (that is when I started to collect the tools and such I needed). I use their skirting as a backup if FS is out of it. If I had to buy hooks and no skirting, went LPO all the way. If I had to buy skirting, and just had to buy hooks from LPO I would just buy from FS to save shipping. I just purchased 500 5/0 Premium Eagle Claw since I have seen they are a lot better then the Mustads now so if these pan out like they are being said, I will be doing more business with LPO on hooks. I use them for my rubber materials, some hair I can't get at my local cabelas and when I buy molds I buy through them. Spinnerbait heads, some other heads that I love that they don't have molds for. Great customer service. The only problem I had was I ordered some trokar hooks and they sent the wrong ones. They then sent the right ones and they got lost in the mail so they sent another package. The lady then told me to keep every hook they sent me and if the lost ones show up to keep them. They were very helpful and polite.
Barlows - First time I ordered, I was not happy because it took almost 3 weeks to get my order. No call no nothing. Well time came where I needed some teflon pins .... So while I was there ordering I figured they give a dang good price on those Trokar jig hooks that I ordered me a few packs to make the 8 dollar shipping worth it ... 3 days later it was there. I use them for my Trokar hooks and teflon pins and some other odds and ends and always get my order within a few days.