I'd suggest getting a sample from the different manufacturers. I prefer the Bait Plastics 312 Saltwater or 362 Saltwater Super Tough as the price and service is good.
Is it the new formula? They switched plastisol suppliers at the beginning of the year.
They used to buy all there plastisol from Bait Plastics and I prefer the old formula so I just get it direct from BP now. I would contact them direct if still having issues.