I emailed the company and this is the response I got within 1 day...
I have a roll in my hand, Aluminum Foil Tape, HVAC, #03202, that is 'glossy', not 'brushed'. However, I don't see any stores in Florida that are currently carrying this. I will send you a roll, which should arrive in about 5 days.
Tammy kicks butt. So for the record...
The product ID is the last 5 digits of the bar code number.
Brushed aluminum tape: 03203
Faux chrome shiney tape: 03202